Post by Thomas McKown on Jul 19, 2010 0:06:46 GMT -5
*Guidelines:*
Don't be shy to this forum if you don't feel like a very experienced photographer. As photographers, some of the most valuable opinions are those of the general public because this is who we are trying to appeal to. Keep in mind that everybody has an opinion and sharing that opinion can benefit others greatly.
The more you critique, the more you will learn about what it is that you like and don't like. In fact, some find that they sometimes learn more when critiquing other photos than when they receive a critique of their own photo!
- If you are unsure how to critique an image, you can choose to follow this simple formula:
1. State what you like about the picture.
2. Point out what needs to be improved on a technical level. (e.g. exposure, color, sharpening...)
3. State what in your opinion could improve the picture from an artistic standpoint. (e.g. composition, saturation, expression...)
4. Follow up with any final thoughts. - You don't have to follow every step if you have nothing to add, but a vague like or dislike is not commonly very constructive.
- Just because a critique is harsh does not mean it was intended to judge you personally. If you receive a negative critique, don't post an aggressive response. You are asking for an opinion, so you must graciously accept what people are generous enough to offer.
- Being very critical can be very constructive, but be careful to always be respectful and polite. Think about how you would feel if somebody said the same thing about one of your photos.
- Critique the photo, not the photographer or the other critics.